Prices for 1951 Topps Magic Football Cards

1951 Topps Magic card list & price guide. Ungraded & graded values for all '51 Topps Magic Football Cards.

Click on any card to see more graded card prices, historic prices, and past sales.

Prices are updated daily based upon 1951 Topps Magic listings that sold on eBay and our marketplace. Read our methodology.

Shortcuts: Most Expensive, Cheapest, List by Card #

You own: 0 / 189 items 0% Track your collection for free

SportsCardsPro Index: 1951 Topps Magic

Average ungraded base card value (excludes parallels) for 1951 Topps Magic | Compare vs.

Premium: Download Price List

Sort & Filter +

Sort by

Card Number


Rookies Only

Variants

Images

Collection



You can filter lists by card number and rookie cards.

You can change the sort order too. This will be remembered as your default for future visits.
Ok
  Card Ungraded Grade 9 PSA 10
Jimmy Monahan #1 $6.31 $229.66 $1,497.89
  • + Wishlist
Vic Janowicz #10 $46.75 $1,629.48 $10,852.11
  • + Wishlist
Capt. Lloyd Hill #11 $5.03
  • + Wishlist
Jim Weatherall [UN Rubbed] #12 $7.29
  • + Wishlist
Lou D'Achille #14 $5.00 $184.06 $1,193.11
  • + Wishlist
Jerrell Price #16 $5.65 $204.95 $1,332.72
  • + Wishlist
John Coatta #17 $5.53 $202.51 $1,316.44
  • + Wishlist
John Coatta [UN Rubbed] #17 $80.00
  • + Wishlist
Bruce Patton #18 $4.20 $156.97 $1,012.11
  • + Wishlist
Bill Wade #2 $13.24 $470.36 $3,106.35
  • + Wishlist
Blaine Earon #20 $4.72 $174.29 $1,127.87
  • + Wishlist
Dewey McConnell #21 $9.96 $356.73 $2,346.98
  • + Wishlist
Dewey McConnell [UN Rubbed] #21 $5.75
  • + Wishlist
Ray Beck #22 $5.70 $209.91 $1,365.87
  • + Wishlist
Walt Trillhaase #26 $4.16 $154.88 $998.16
  • + Wishlist
Gil Bartosh #27 $5.81 $212.89 $1,385.80
  • + Wishlist
Gil Bartosh [UN Rubbed] #27 $1.99
  • + Wishlist
Bob Bestwick [UN Rubbed] #28 $35.00
  • + Wishlist
Tom Rushing [UN Rubbed] #29 $4.00
  • + Wishlist
William Reichardt [UN Rubbed] #3 $80.00
  • + Wishlist
Bert Rechichar #30 $7.99 $288.15 $1,888.70
  • + Wishlist
Mike Goggins #32 $6.10 $222.28 $1,448.51
  • + Wishlist
Byron Townsend #34 $5.14 $188.88 $1,225.37
  • + Wishlist
Ed Rotticci #35 $4.26 $182.32 $1,181.51
  • + Wishlist
Steve Wadiak [UN Rubbed] #36 $11.50 $410.49 $2,706.25
  • + Wishlist
Bobby Marlow #37 $4.50 $167.00 $1,079.16
  • + Wishlist
Ralph Staub #39 $6.40 $234.19 $1,528.13
  • + Wishlist
Babe Parilli #4 $18.90 $664.86 $4,406.04
  • + Wishlist
Bill Vesprini #40 $2.85 $103.63 $655.69
  • + Wishlist
Zack Jordan #41 $5.36 $196.92 $1,279.09
  • + Wishlist
Zack Jordan [UN Rubbed] #41 $11.00
  • + Wishlist
Bob Smith #42 $7.65 $273.45 $1,790.45
  • + Wishlist
Bill Putich #47 $6.50 $236.28 $1,542.09
  • + Wishlist
Bill Putich [UN Rubbed] #47 $6.25
  • + Wishlist
George Young #48 $9.35 $320.31 $2,103.65
  • + Wishlist
George Young [UN Rubbed] #48 $14.15 $502.48 $3,320.92
  • + Wishlist
Capt. Don McRae #49 $3.00
  • + Wishlist
Bill Burkhalter #5 $6.35
  • + Wishlist
Bill Burkhalter [UN Rubbed] #5 $85.00
  • + Wishlist
Frank Smith [UN Rubbed] #50 $7.00
  • + Wishlist
Clyde Pickard #52 $3.64 $136.02 $872.12
  • + Wishlist
Bob Reynolds #53 $6.16 $223.13 $1,454.24
  • + Wishlist
Dick Gregory #54 $4.26 $158.65 $1,023.32
  • + Wishlist
Dale Samuels #55 $5.29 $193.06 $1,253.27
  • + Wishlist
Capt. Vic Pujo #57 $2.25
  • + Wishlist
Capt. Vic Pujo [UN Rubbed] #57 $5.75
  • + Wishlist
Nick Liotta #61 $5.20 $197.62 $1,283.73
  • + Wishlist
Hi Faubion #63 $9.00 $323.24 $2,123.18
  • + Wishlist
Hi Faubion [UN Rubbed] #63 $6.25
  • + Wishlist
Carroll McDonald #66 $4.50 $166.65 $1,076.83
  • + Wishlist

FAQ | Login Don't Want Ads?

Take/Upload a sports card photo. Find the best match in our database.

Example Photos

Great Photo
great photo example
  • Clear Photo
  • Rectangle Shaped Card
  • Minimal Background
Bad Photo = Poor Result
bad photo: too much background and blurry
  • Too Much Background
  • Blurry
Bad Photo = Poor Result
bad photo: angled edges
  • Shot From an Angle So
    Card is Not a Rectangle
Bad Photo = Poor Result
bad photo: cutoff
  • Cutoff Part of Card

Best Matches